Total caps won at Everton (total caps won including other clubs given in brackets).
| Player | Country | Caps won at Everton | (total caps won) |
| Alan Ball | England | 39 | (72) |
| David Weir | Scotland | 45 | (69) |
| Neville Southall | Wales | 92 | (92) |
| Alex Stevenson | Northern Ireland | 14 | (17) |
| Kevin Sheedy | Republic of Ireland | 41 | (45) |